The First Test of Leadership
Remember Sandpapergate? It refers to the Third Test between South Africa and Australia in Cape Town in 2018, where Cameron Bancroft, playing in only his eighth Test, was caught on camera stuffing a piece of sandpaper down his trousers.
Most cricketers, whether weekend park players or professionals, will readily tell you it is commonplace to ‘work’ on the ball. Using sandpaper is not. It’s forbidden, and using it on the field is both wrong and stupid.
Sandpapergate became a national disgrace, with everyone from the Prime Minister down expressing a suitably embarrassed opinion on it. Ultimately, three men were blamed: Bancroft, who received a nine-month suspension, and then captain Steve Smith and vice-captain David Warner, both of whom received a 12-month suspension.
All of this is back in the headlines again because the retired Test opener Usman Khawaja has written about it in his autobiography, Sabr. It’s only one chapter in a 30-chapter book, but it’s the one everyone has focused on because Khawaja opens the chapter with a dedication to the three banned players, and puts the case that the team should have taken responsibility for what happened.
In an interview on the ABC’s flagship current affairs program, 7.30, Khawaja was pressed to name who knew what and when, and was specifically asked whether current Test captain, Pat Cummins, knew. Khawaja repeatedly declined to answer, emphasising that this was “his story” and that he couldn’t speak for other people.
Attention, of course, then turned to Cummins, who called a media conference last week to address Sandpapergate. He told reporters:
“When Khawaja says, we all knew…if by that he means that we knew sandpaper was going out on the field, he's 100% wrong. I've said that consistently for the last eight years. I did not know that was happening."
So many have enthused, some of them cloyingly, about Cummins’s ‘leadership’ because he spent 68 minutes answering questions until there were no more. It was straight from the playbook of Alan Alda’s character, Arnold Vinick, in The West Wing, who did it as a piece of campaign stagecraft.
But was it leadership?
What Cummins actually did was frame the narrative to suit his position and protect his reputation.
I’ve read Khawaja’s book. His main point in the Sandpaper chapter is not about who knew what and when. It is about how the team operated, and the decision taken to pin blame on three players rather than the entire team. What Khawaja regrets is the lack of collective responsibility.
Nowhere in the book does Khawaja say, as Cummins claimed, that Cummins and the other bowlers were “architects of a scheme to ball tamper with sandpaper”. Nowhere does Khawaja say that everyone knew that Bancroft had taken it on to the field. In fact, the only mention of Cummins in the entire chapter is to talk about the ball in the First Test “naturally reversing”. He makes the observation that with players the calibre of Cummins et al, and the ball naturally reversing and spinning, “you’re probably going to win”. (Australia did win that First Test).
Khawaja sets out the context of what happened on the day in detail. He describes a win-at-all-costs environment, and extensive team talks throughout the series about the need to get the ball reversing, because that was seen as the only way to win. There were experiments with sandpaper in the dressing room, which led to Bancroft ‘working’ the ball during the Second Test in Port Elizabeth (now Gqeberha) as the team went back out after a break. Even so, Australia lost that Test by six wickets.
In Cape Town, Khawaja explains that a dividing wall split the dressing room, so the team weren’t all in the same space. He was seated next to Bancroft when he picked up the sandpaper and put it in his pocket, after a member of the coaching staff urged him to do “more of it”.
Khawaja writes that rather than apportion blame to Bancroft, Smith and Warner, the view he expressed at the time was that the team should “…cop this as a team.”
He goes on to write:
“But I believe that we won as a team, we lost as a team, and we should take responsibility and ownership as a team.”
For anyone who has been part of a team, whether amateur or professional, that is standard. Football dressing rooms live by the same code.
According to Khawaja’s account, the team manager, Gavin Dovey, agreed but told Khawaja that “two guys in the team disagreed”. Khawaja does not name them in the book.
Chadd Sayers, the 12th man who says he carried sandpaper off the field at the Port Elizabeth Test, agrees with Khawaja’s recollection.
Tim Paine, who was appointed captain after Smith was forced out, also has a chapter on Sandpapergate in his 2022 autobiography, The Price Paid. He uses similar words to Cummins about not knowing the sandpaper was ‘on the field’. But he also writes that “everyone was part of it to some degree” and that it would have been better if “we owned it as a team”.
Cummins could have taken the same approach as Paine. He could have said he knew nothing about sandpaper being “on the field”, if that is the case, but agreed that there should have been collective responsibility. After all, that is the essence of what a team is about.
Khawaja, meanwhile, has refused to name names in his book and on national television, even under direct questioning. He has kept his argument about the team, not individuals.
Being a team player is the first test of leadership. If you’re looking for an example of a team man, we could do worse than start with Usman Khawaja.
This piece was first published in Nick Harris's Sporting Intelligence substack.


